Top 7 Black Eyeliner Pencils for Stunning Eye Makeup Looks

Black eyeliner pencils have long been a staple in makeup collections worldwide. They serve as an essential tool for enhancing the eyes, allowing for endless looks that range from sharp and bold to soft and smoky. With an array of options available, from high-end luxury brands to affordable drugstore varieties, finding the perfect black eyeliner pencil can feel overwhelming. In this article, we'll explore the top seven black eyeliner pencils that have garnered attention and praise from makeup enthusiasts, highlighting their unique features, applications, and how they can elevate your eye makeup game.

Understanding Black Eyeliner Pencils

Black eyeliner pencils come in various forms, including kohl, gel, and traditional wax-based options. Each type offers distinct advantages depending on personal preferences, desired looks, and occasions.

1. The Classic Kohl Pencils

Kohl pencils are known for their soft texture that allows for easy blending and smudging. They are ideal for creating a smoky eye look and can be worn on the waterline. However, kohl can smudge more easily than other types, so it’s essential to set it properly if you need longevity.

2. Gel Liners

Gel liners come in pencil form but deliver the rich, pigmented finish of traditional gel liner. They often provide better staying power than kohl and can be used for more precise lines.

3. Wax-Based Pencils

Traditional wax-based pencils are the most common type found in makeup aisles. They vary widely in formula, and brands often incorporate unique ingredients to enhance performance. These pencils can offer a matte or glossy finish depending on the formulation.

Top 7 Black Eyeliner Pencils

Now, let’s delve into our curated list of seven black eyeliner pencils that stand out in both performance and user satisfaction.

1. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Zero

Urban Decay has earned a reputation for creating exceptional eye products, and the 24/7 Glide-On Pencil is no exception. ""Zero"" is a modern classic known for its deep black color and creamy texture that glides on effortlessly. While its staying power is moderate compared to some long-wear options, the ease of application and ability to achieve a perfectly blended line makes this pencil a favorite for smoky looks. Priced at $19, it can be found at Sephora and other major retailers.

2. NARS Larger Than Life Long-Wear Eye Pencil in Via Veneto

If you're looking for staying power, NARS' ""Via Veneto"" will be your new go-to. This pencil boasts an impressive longevity, making it a workhorse product. The formula glides on, creating a rich, dark line without pulling at the delicate eye area. At $24, this pencil is available at NARS counters and online at narscosmetics.com.

3. Hourglass Film Noir Kohl Pencil in Eclipse Black

For those drawn to elegant packaging and luxury formulations, Hourglass' Film Noir Kohl Pencil is a must-try. ""Eclipse Black"" is extremely soft, allowing for easy application, particularly suited for dramatic winter looks. However, makeup lovers might find it too creamy for hot weather, as it may smudge. It retails for $28, found at Hourglass counters and online.

4. Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen in Black Noir

A fantastic bargain for a reliable pencil, Pixi’s ""Black Noir"" is known for its intense color payoff and excellent longevity. While it may not offer the most unique shade of black, its performance is stellar and—best of all—it's easily accessible at Target. At $15, it’s an ideal option for makeup emergencies.

5. Lancôme Le Crayon Kohl in Black Ebony

Lancôme's Le Crayon Kohl is a true classic that has stood the test of time. ""Black Ebony"" is perfect for the waterline and great for smudging, although it may not be as jaggedly dark as newer competitors. A versatile staple for over a decade, it retails at $26 and can be found at major beauty counters.

6. Armani Eyes to Kill Waterproof Liner

Once a limited edition hit, this liner is now part of the permanent range. The ""Eyes to Kill"" Waterproof Liner is renowned for its powerful color payoff and impeccable waterproof formula. It’s perfect for those long days when you need your eyeliner to stay put. Available for $28, you can purchase it through Giorgio Armani Beauty.

7. Yves Saint Laurent Waterproof Eye Pencil in Black Ink

If you’re looking for high-end luxury, the YSL Waterproof Eye Pencil in ""Black Ink"" is a stunning addition. Though its price tag of $30 may be steep, this pencil offers an incredible depth of color and long-lasting wear. Despite some complaints about the pencil running out quickly, its smooth application makes it worth the investment. Available at YSL counters and online.

Choosing the Right Eyeliner for You

When selecting a black eyeliner pencil, consider factors such as:

1. Texture and Formulation

Choose a pencil texture that suits your makeup style. If you prefer a softer, more smudged look, go for kohl. For precise lines that last, opt for gel or waterproof styles.

2. Occasion

Consider when you’ll be wearing the eyeliner. For daily wear, you might want something with moderate staying power. For events or photos, select a longer-lasting option.

3. Eye Sensitivity

If you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, ensure the pencil is ophthalmologist-tested and suitable for sensitive skin.

Balancing Performance and Price

Makeup is a realm where personal preference often outweighs price. It’s essential to find a pencil that performs well within your budget. Don’t hesitate to explore different brands and prices until you find your perfect match.

Conclusion

Finding the best black eyeliner pencil is a journey of personal preference and trial. The options listed above cover a range of functionalities, formulas, and price points, making them accessible to all makeup lovers. Whether you're creating a simple line for everyday wear or designing a sultry smoky eye for a night out, having a reliable black eyeliner pencil is essential.

FAQ